Switch to Linear ModeSwitch to Hybrid ModeSwitch to Threaded Mode
Printer Friendly View | Email this page | Register Now to enjoy user benefits! | Share on Share on Facebook
NightRaven Home Of The Hardcores


Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Singapore
Posts: 16,712
Trade rep: 52 (100%)
Battle at the top - Asus Maximus Formula VS Asus Blitz Formula NightRaven Oct 13th, 07, 09:02 PM #1 (permalink)
woo! one look and i knew this was going to get exciting! 2 top end boards from the ROG series! similiar features etc same brand but different chipset.

have a look at how it has been going.. the results are going to surprise u.. it sure surprised me. also look at my conclusion and personal opinions

plus some findings i made....


PS: i'm no screen shot guy much. this kind i dont like to post screens. guys who know me know. there will just be TOO many! i dont like looking at too many. so... i'll just put the scores down!


Test Setup
Intel Core 2 E6550 @ 400x6 2.4ghz
Kingston DDR2 533 flashed 667 running at 1000mhz 5-4-4-8 2T D9 GMH
Asus Blitz Formula 1101 + Maximus Formula 0401
Asus 8600GT @ 540/600
Coolermaster 600W

Click the image to open in full size.

Click the image to open in full size.

Click the image to open in full size.

Click the image to open in full size.

Click the image to open in full size.


Here lies what i dont understand. see the pushpin. means u cant take out the heatsinks and pipes cuz u cant take out the push pin. its exactly fitting - means it cant pop up. (apparently i do think that the heatsink is actually 2 parts instead of one. the pwm is one piece and the nb sb one piece. if that is so then there's no prob)

Click the image to open in full size.


Having a sloping top pwm heatsink means no optional fan?
Click the image to open in full size.

i ran a set of 10 benchmarks TWICE each time, taking the avg score to be sure it was not a freak score.



Programs | Blitz Score | Maximus Score
1) Super Pi 1M (lower better) | 21.156s | 21.266s
2) Super Pi 8M (lower better) | 4m 4s 313ms | 4m 6s 781ms
3) Sandra Proc Arith (higher better) | ALU- 22226 isse3- 15268 | ALU- 22220 isse3- 15264
4) Sandra Proc MultiMedia (higher better) | issse3 132236 isse2 71636| issse3- 132237 isse2- 71633
5) Sandra Mem Bandwidth (higher better) | INt - 7061 FLoat - 7087 | int - 6695 float - 6708
6) Sandra Mem Latency (lower better) | 70ns | 79ns
7) 3dmark01 (higher better) | 35118 | 34309
8) 3dmark03 (higher better) | 16294 | 15094
9) 3dmark05 (higher better) | 9560 | 8805
10) Company of heros 1024*768 MAX details (higher better) | AVG 49.4 MAX 141.7 Min 24.6| AVG 42.7 MAX 135 Min 21.6

* i took away 06 and pcmark05 due to come problems. now i have my blitz with a quad and i feel its gonna be unfair even if i run with affinity. so i will only take benches that rely mostly on speed and not multi core.


Conclusion and thoughts
First i wanna address why i am running all again. For some reason, i kept getting BSOD about my RAMs when they were known and rated to do 1000 5-4-4-8 at less than 2.2V. I have read around and even have a friend - longsiew who found the board easy to clock. whereas in this case, i found my blitz to clock better and easier.

FSB walls were similiar to the blitz, rams i am testing further as you read this and as i test the remaining benchmarks again. longsiew mentioned abt the board liking d9 gmh memory. as with the blitz, i agree that is true on both boards. HOwever in comparison to the blitz, once again i say, its harder to scale.

Also flashing the BIOS to the later 05 version screwed my clocks to hell. it could not even clock well after i flashed it. from 550fsb to a mere 520! no way! something was wrong and is wrong. i flashed it back to bring u this review first. time allowing i will find out what is wrong.


It is weird that the blitz beats the maximus in all tests, considering the x38 was to be the faster better chipset. i note that the board was cooler overall, but what good is that if performance is not up to par.


Some possibilities some friends and myself came up with are bios, bandwidth - 400fsb not high enough!?, and just the chipset itself - since my bro from Indonesia, AndreX_X has mentioned in vrzone regarding this gigabyte x38-dq6.


all i can say at this moment is that everything is still a mess imo. i will be testing more to find out more also. some issues in the back of my mind are BSODs users have been reporting - i have none except for the rams thing. and i must say, the blitz has the 3 led boot issue, this board has the 3 led bios recovery issue! it justs sits there and dosent recover ur failed overclock! again u have to cut electricity to the system as clr cmos does not work.


i do think that with a more mature bios, the maximus will show its true potential. i could be wrong but i am sure of one thing, the maximus extreme - ddr3 will fly

Intel Extreme CPUs | Gigabyte & Asus Motherboards | Gskill DDR3 | MSI + Gigabyte + Asus GFX | Thermaltake 1000W | Gskill SSDs | K|ngp|n's Dragon F1 Extreme 'NightRaven' Edition Ln2 CPU Pot | K|ngp|n's Tek 9 5.0 Ln2 GPU Pot
 
Last edited by NightRaven; Oct 15th, 07 at 08:46 PM..
Gollum
Gollum's Avatar
Registered User


Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: The Lost Valley
Posts: 24,299
Trade rep: 20 (100%)
Gollum Oct 13th, 07, 09:37 PM #2 (permalink)
too tired to give u a witty rebuttal. y not repost again with the results and findings instead of just a link?
"Now, now, my good man, this is no time for making enemies." -- Voltaire His last words on his death bed when asked by a priest to renounce Satan.
 
NightRaven Home Of The Hardcores


Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Singapore
Posts: 16,712
Trade rep: 52 (100%)
NightRaven Oct 13th, 07, 10:37 PM #3 (permalink)
um okie. yea appreaciate that. am too tired also here to repost everything....ah maybe when i am done testing
Intel Extreme CPUs | Gigabyte & Asus Motherboards | Gskill DDR3 | MSI + Gigabyte + Asus GFX | Thermaltake 1000W | Gskill SSDs | K|ngp|n's Dragon F1 Extreme 'NightRaven' Edition Ln2 CPU Pot | K|ngp|n's Tek 9 5.0 Ln2 GPU Pot
 
Evange
Evange's Avatar
Strategist Mind


Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 3,227
Trade rep: 8 (100%)
Thanked 1 Times in 1 Post
Evange Oct 13th, 07, 11:32 PM #4 (permalink)
Huh... See nothing leh...
 
NightRaven Home Of The Hardcores


Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Singapore
Posts: 16,712
Trade rep: 52 (100%)
NightRaven Oct 13th, 07, 11:34 PM #5 (permalink)
ya sorrie bro can u go other forum find first? i now finishing up the last few tests again. u find other forums, have my thread. same title.
Intel Extreme CPUs | Gigabyte & Asus Motherboards | Gskill DDR3 | MSI + Gigabyte + Asus GFX | Thermaltake 1000W | Gskill SSDs | K|ngp|n's Dragon F1 Extreme 'NightRaven' Edition Ln2 CPU Pot | K|ngp|n's Tek 9 5.0 Ln2 GPU Pot
 
quadroyal Registered User


Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 1,163
Trade rep: 0 (0%)
quadroyal Oct 14th, 07, 12:41 AM #6 (permalink)
Quote:
Originally Posted by NightRaven View Post
um okie. yea appreaciate that. am too tired also here to repost everything....ah maybe when i am done testing
then dun post lor. u r under no obligation too
 
NightRaven Home Of The Hardcores


Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Singapore
Posts: 16,712
Trade rep: 52 (100%)
NightRaven Oct 14th, 07, 12:47 AM #7 (permalink)
Quote:
Originally Posted by quadroyal View Post
then dun post lor. u r under no obligation too
ur really selfish.

i under no obligation yes. but i still help. if ur not interested then nvm.. OTHERs still want to know.
Intel Extreme CPUs | Gigabyte & Asus Motherboards | Gskill DDR3 | MSI + Gigabyte + Asus GFX | Thermaltake 1000W | Gskill SSDs | K|ngp|n's Dragon F1 Extreme 'NightRaven' Edition Ln2 CPU Pot | K|ngp|n's Tek 9 5.0 Ln2 GPU Pot
 
zechraffie
zechraffie's Avatar
ex Apple Lisa User


Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 1,423
Trade rep: 15 (100%)
zechraffie Oct 14th, 07, 01:03 AM #8 (permalink)
Quote:
Originally Posted by quadroyal View Post
then dun post lor. u r under no obligation too
you're under no obligation to read too
Dell XPS M1330 User?
Email me at zechraffie@yahoo.co.uk and you may get a FREE upgraded Dell
 
zechraffie
zechraffie's Avatar
ex Apple Lisa User


Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 1,423
Trade rep: 15 (100%)
zechraffie Oct 14th, 07, 01:06 AM #9 (permalink)
Quote:
Originally Posted by NightRaven View Post
ur really selfish.

i under no obligation yes. but i still help. if ur not interested then nvm.. OTHERs still want to know.
Yep NR bro, i'm one of those willing to wait for your results and thanks for the efforts
Dell XPS M1330 User?
Email me at zechraffie@yahoo.co.uk and you may get a FREE upgraded Dell
 
hdchopper
hdchopper's Avatar
Registered User


Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: ARIZONA US
Posts: 331
Trade rep: 0 (0%)
hdchopper Oct 14th, 07, 01:39 AM #10 (permalink)
eye got all the time in the world
can always wait for a NR report !!


FOXCONN MARS vdroop .04
PENT E8400 o/c 4.2 at 526x8 1.36v & 4.7 at 1.45
COOLIT eliminator 7*c idle ~ 38*c load
piped into house a/c
BUFFALO FIRESTIX 800 cl5 2X1 gig sticks thay do 1202 eazy
OCZ Vertex SSD
ATI 3870 X2
Quattro 1000W
In the Works Asus P6T SE
 
NightRaven Home Of The Hardcores


Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Singapore
Posts: 16,712
Trade rep: 52 (100%)
NightRaven Oct 14th, 07, 01:43 PM #11 (permalink)
thanks guys done
Intel Extreme CPUs | Gigabyte & Asus Motherboards | Gskill DDR3 | MSI + Gigabyte + Asus GFX | Thermaltake 1000W | Gskill SSDs | K|ngp|n's Dragon F1 Extreme 'NightRaven' Edition Ln2 CPU Pot | K|ngp|n's Tek 9 5.0 Ln2 GPU Pot
 
XTimX
XTimX's Avatar
私は黒髪ロリです


Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: 熊熊-様の中にと金髪ロリ-ちゃんの隣に
Posts: 18,404
Trade rep: 55 (98%)
XTimX Oct 14th, 07, 02:58 PM #12 (permalink)
woot nice there man...think I'm poisoned by blitz now yeah ?

NR here is just trying to help and if you have actually benched and stuff , you will understand how tiring and troublesome it is quadroyal. to be honest , it isn't fun at all

Give the man a break...
 
organism Guest


Posts: n/a
Trade rep: (%)
organism Oct 14th, 07, 05:06 PM #13 (permalink)
hope can have 1 of your gear.
 
T_M
T_M's Avatar
Aussie


Join Date: May 2006
Location: Jakarta, Indonesia
Posts: 1,062
Trade rep: 8 (90%)
T_M Oct 14th, 07, 06:45 PM #14 (permalink)
X38 is WAY too random still to count on any results being conclusive.
Hence why many distro's recalling the boards
 
harshal
harshal's Avatar
Knowledge is Freedom


Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Mumbai, India
Posts: 258
Trade rep: 0 (0%)
Thanked 1 Times in 1 Post
harshal Oct 14th, 07, 06:51 PM #15 (permalink)
What??? X38 boards being recalled??
Freeze!!!
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Linear Mode Linear Mode
Featured Retailer
OCZ Fan Club!
OCZ Fan Club 35 OCZ Fans!
Kingston Fan Club!
Kingston Fan Club Join Now!